top of page

Iryna Zarutska’s Family Wants Answers. Charlotte Wants the Lawsuit Dismissed.

14 minutes ago
6 min read

By NC Bail Network | November 19, 2026

Mural of a blonde woman’s face on a blue sky wall, with yellow and blue flowers at the base and leafy shadows.
Honoring the memory of Iryna Zarutska, surrounded by blossoms and the gentle glow of a candle, symbolizing peace and remembrance.

Remembering Iryna Zarutska


Iryna Zarutska came to North Carolina after fleeing the war in Ukraine with her family. At just 23 years old, she was building a life in Charlotte, working at a local pizzeria and improving her English. Her uncle said she hoped to go to school to become a veterinary assistant.

On August 22, 2025, Iryna boarded Charlotte’s Lynx Blue Line after work. She should have been able to make that trip home safely.

Instead, Iryna was violently attacked while sitting on the train. According to investigators, a man seated behind her pulled out a knife, unfolded it, stood up, and struck at her three times. He stabbed her in the neck and then walked away. Iryna lost consciousness shortly afterward and died at the scene. Investigators reported no apparent interaction between them before the attack.

Video of the attack later circulated widely on social media, exposing people across the country to the horrific final moments of an innocent young woman’s life. Behind those images was a real person... a daughter, sister, and loved one whose life was taken far too soon.

DeCarlos Brown Jr. was arrested and charged in connection with her death. He faces a state murder charge and a federal charge related to an act of violence causing death on a mass transportation system. His criminal cases have been delayed after findings that he was incapable of proceeding to trial. The charges remain allegations until resolved in court.

Iryna’s death left a family grieving and a community asking how something so devastating could happen. It also brought national attention to public safety, mental health, and North Carolina’s pretrial release system.

More than a year later, her name remains connected to two separate developments: a wrongful death lawsuit against the City of Charlotte and its transit security contractor, and changes to the implementation of a portion of Iryna’s Law.

Painted mural of a blonde woman at sunrise with sunflowers, blue flowers, and a North Carolina Bail Bond Network logo.
A vibrant mural commemorates Iryna Zarutrska, blending symbols of the Ukrainian spirit in a picturesque landscape, as sunflowers and blue flowers frame a serene portrait beneath the national flag's colors.

The lawsuit over Iryna’s death


In August 2026, the administrator of Iryna’s estate filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the City of Charlotte and Professional Police Services, Inc., which did business as Professional Security Services.

The lawsuit alleges that the defendants knew about safety concerns on and around the transit system and failed to take reasonable steps to protect passengers. The complaint points to issues involving security staffing, monitoring, fare enforcement, and access barriers.

These are allegations in a civil lawsuit. A court has not established them as findings of fact.


Why Charlotte is claiming governmental immunity

Charlotte has asked a judge to dismiss the claims against the city. In its response, the city denied that it ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused the attack.


Among its defenses, Charlotte argues that decisions involving police deployment, transit security, crime prevention, and public safety administration are governmental functions protected by governmental immunity.


The city also argues that, if claims against it are allowed to proceed, payments arising from Iryna’s injuries and death should be subject to a cumulative $1 million limit. That, too, is the city’s legal argument... not a court determination reported here.


Governmental immunity can protect a government entity from certain lawsuits, but whether it applies depends on the law and the facts of the case. Raising the defense does not automatically end a lawsuit. A judge must consider the parties’ arguments.


The city’s motion also does not decide the separate criminal case or establish whether the private security contractor is liable.

Dusk garden with wet brick path, lit candles, bench, flowers, and mural of Iryna Zarutska 2002-2025 beside a city skyline.
A tranquil urban garden at dusk, with a memorial mural tribute to Iryna Zarutska on a brick wall, beautifully illuminated by warm string lights and surrounded by vibrant flowers and candlelit benches.

Where Iryna’s Law fits in


Following Iryna’s death, North Carolina lawmakers enacted Iryna’s Law in 2025. Named in her memory, the law made several changes involving pretrial release and other criminal justice procedures.

On September 29, 2025, Michael Woody, owner and CEO of 828 Bail Bonds, testified at a congressional field hearing in Charlotte focused on victims of violent crime. During his testimony, Woody spoke about Iryna, voiced his concerns about unsecured pretrial release, and expressed support for reforms like Iryna’s Law. The governor signed the legislation days after the hearing.

Woody’s participation was part of a broader conversation about how communities can honor Iryna’s memory and work toward a system that considers public safety, accountability, and the needs of victims and their families.

Among its provisions, Iryna’s Law requires officers to inform a judicial official setting pretrial release conditions about relevant behavior they observed that may indicate a defendant is a danger to themselves or others.

It also created additional pretrial release requirements for certain defendants charged with violent offenses or with significant criminal histories. Several of those provisions took effect on December 1, 2025.


The civil lawsuit and Iryna’s Law address different questions. The lawsuit concerns alleged transit safety failures and whether the defendants can be held civilly responsible. The law addresses pretrial release and other criminal justice procedures statewide.


What part of Iryna’s Law was delayed?


One part of Iryna’s Law deals with what happens when someone is arrested and there are serious concerns about their mental health or safety.

This provision, found in G.S. 15A-533(b1), was scheduled to take effect on December 1, 2026. Lawmakers have since moved that date to July 1, 2028.

Once it takes effect, the provision will require a judicial official... such as a judge or magistrate, to order an initial examination in two situations:

  • The person is charged with a violent offense, and court records show they were subject to an involuntary commitment order within the previous three years; or

  • The person is charged with any offense, and the judicial official has reasonable grounds to believe they are a danger to themselves or others.

An involuntary commitment order is a court order connected to a process that can require someone to receive mental health or substance use treatment under certain legal conditions.

Under the delayed provision, law enforcement would transport the person to a hospital emergency department or another crisis facility for an initial examination. A qualified examiner would then decide whether there are grounds to request involuntary commitment.


An examination does not automatically mean a person will be committed. What happens next depends on the examiner’s findings, whether the examiner issues a commitment petition and custody order, and whether the person has met other conditions of release, such as a bond when one is required.

Does this mean Iryna’s Law is on hold?

No. This particular examination process has been delayed until July 2028. Other parts of Iryna’s Law, including changes to pretrial release, are already in effect.

It’s also important to understand that delaying this new process does not mean mental health evaluations or involuntary commitment cannot happen before 2028. Other North Carolina laws already provide processes for addressing those concerns.

Painterly portrait of a blonde woman amid yellow flowers under a starry blue sky, with a North Carolina Bail Bond Network seal.
A heartfelt tribute to Iryna Zarutska, surrounded by vibrant yellow flowers and a starry night sky, capturing her enduring spirit and warmth.

Why this matters to our community


Iryna’s death affected a family, a community, and people across North Carolina who followed her story. It also raised questions about public safety, access to mental health care, and how different parts of our justice system respond when someone is in crisis.

The lawsuit will allow the courts to consider the claims and defenses surrounding transit safety and responsibility. Questions about Iryna’s Law will continue as its provisions are put into practice.

As those conversations continue, we should remember the person at their center. Iryna was a daughter, a sister, and a young woman building a life in North Carolina. She deserved to feel safe on her way home, and her family deserved more time with her.

Our hearts remain with Iryna’s family and everyone who loved her. NC Bail Network will continue following these developments and sharing updates with our community. 💙💛

This article is for informational purposes and is not legal advice. Court proceedings and laws can change; consult an attorney about a specific situation.

Sources for publication:

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page